Showing posts with label Warnock. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Warnock. Show all posts

Tuesday, 10 January 2012

Q.P.Huh?

Warnock out, Hughes in... trigger-happy, or clever foresight?

On Sunday, Neil Warnock was unexpectedly dismissed from his post as QPR manager. Millions wept. A silence of despair hanged over Loftus Road. A nation poured its heart out towards the beloved, fallen hero. Things will simply never be the same again.

In truth, the firing of Warnock suggests a puzzling indictment upon Malaysian moneyman Tony Fernandes as a chairman. Indeed, the induction to the Premier League for Rangers was always going to be bumpier than a lift from Mel Gibson, but viewing the situation with a general perspective it seemed they were doing OK. Avoiding relegation was the priority of this season and currently they sit just above the drop zone. If QPR were to end the campaign in 17th, it would have to be regarded as a success (albeit a muted one).

But if you look beyond that point, this decision starts to make a lot of sense in a few different ways. The main and most face-bashingly obvious point to make is that QPR’s form has been atrocious in recent weeks, with eight winless games culminating into a disappointing and yet fortuitous draw against League One MK Dons. You could argue that MK Dons aside, QPR’s recent fixtures have been tough, but relegation candidates need to keep picking up points whether it be from likely places or not. QPR just seem to be devoid of the spirit that carries a victory in this current stretch of form.

Another benefit of this decision is its timing. With Warnock sacked early on in January, grouchy Welshman Mark Hughes now has the advantage of being able to utilise the transfer markets at a more sedate pace. It allows him to analyse the team and work out where changes need to be made as opposed to handing out contracts in a rush whilst his knees jerk everywhere. This sort of forward-planning not only helps Hughes to assess his squad, but also gives Fernandes a head-start in assessing Hughes. If QPR get relegated, Fernandes will have an extra stick with which to beat Mark Hughes, as the manager had a whole transfer window to make changes.

Fernandes also gets brownie points for having a replacement brought in so quickly. There’s nothing worse for a downbeat side than the eternal buzz of backroom whispers, seeping uncertainty into the dressing room. Having a manager implemented with such efficiency prevents that inevitable rocky period as one of the assistants takes over for a couple of games, employs the same tactics as the dismissed manager and realises he isn’t under any pressure to win games. Instead, Hughes can immediately begin preparing for the next fixture, and what would have been a potential big dip in form is ironed out.

It feels cold-hearted to say, but Fernandes may have actually made a very good decision in sacking Warnock. The change of direction from a downturn in form, compounded with a plethora of new and exciting signings, can often save a side at this point in the season. For Portsmouth in 2006, employing Redknapp and allowing him a chunky transfer budget undoubtedly saved the team from relegation (and ironically, ultimately consigned the team to near-abyss).

You have to feel sorry for Warnock. OK, you don’t. You really don’t. But it’s a bum-deal when a manager has orchestrated a promotion but loses his job when things become a struggle the next level up. Often it is frustratingly pointless and unfair – Billy Davies’ sacking in 2007, for example. But in this case, I can see the argument. You may not agree with Fernandes’ decision, but he has pulled it off in the most intelligent way possible.

Tuesday, 1 November 2011

The Folly of Diouf

He’s a bit of a numpty, but sometimes football isn’t the right place for moral postulating.
It was yesterday announced that Senegalese striker El-Hadji Diouf had found himself a new home at the Keepmoat Stadium. Doncaster, who are currently joint-bottom of the Championship, had delved into the dark pits of football’s utterly despicable characters and plucked the most vile, putrid and contemptible human capable of wearing a football shirt out from the stench-filled cavern. Those monsters! How could they?!!!
It’s relatively well-realised that El-Hadji Diouf is one of the most awful people in football. His early career in English football was reminiscent of a lawn sprinkler, with numerous incidents of spitting on players, fans and practically anyone who came within a few feet of him. One of the most grotesquely nasty incidents involving Diouf was during last season’s FA Cup, where Diouf abused Jamie Mackie as he lay on the floor with a broken leg. Following the incident, Neil Warnock insinuated that Diouf was lower in people’s estimations than a sewer rat (thereby tying him with Neil Warnock in many people’s estimations).
But still, Doncaster successfully pursued him. There’s much debate about whether signing a player like Diouf, a man with unquestionable talent, is good for a football club when the man has displayed such a tremendously appalling character in his career. Is it right for a team to be seen justifying the man’s previous incidents with a fresh new contract?
This has been a case made many time before. Marlon King and Lee Hughes are just two examples of players whose reputations suffered following incidents of a much more serious nature than those of Diouf’s. Regardless, both players have gone on to help their clubs achieve more success, and the questions of their former lives gradually faded away from the fans’ thoughts as they performed in games and scored goals.
I think the truth is that whether or not it is right for a person of Diouf’s attitude to be rewarded and paid so fruitfully, it is not the issue of the football club. Of course a team can make a point of not signing a player if they feel it goes against their values, and this would be a nice thing to do, but in many cases it’s just not a situation where being picky and choosy is an option.
Take, for example, Doncaster. They are bottom of the Championship and could well be in a big relegation scrap this year. If Diouf’s goals help them to stay up, the fans won’t have their party spoiled by the fact that Diouf played a role in the survival. That’s just not how things work. Some ambitions in football are too important for the moral high-ground to get in the way, and it would have been no solace to Doncaster if they had turned Diouf down and then got relegated.
Following the death of Colonel Gaddafi, I was pondering the fact that at one time during Portsmouth’s seeming descent into financial meltdown, Gaddafi’s son was rumoured to be interested in buying the club. Given how events turned out, it’s quite good that this didn’t happen, but at the time I was quite comfortable with the thought of a Gaddafi running Portsmouth. Despite the disgusting history of the family, all I wanted was to see my club survive the turmoil, and if that meant allowing the son of a murderous dictator running affairs, well, so be it.
You can accuse me of being a morally bankrupt cur (no idea if that’s an insult, but it sounded nice). Perhaps that’s true, but sometimes in life bad people get good things. It’s a matter of fact, and I don’t think football is the cause of this, nor will it spark the movement that prevents this. Anyone looking to football as a bastion of moral fabric in our society is completely mental. Besides, it’s not like Diouf’s killed anyone…