Showing posts with label Luis Suarez. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Luis Suarez. Show all posts

Sunday, 12 February 2012

Luising His Head

It's not just a controversy. It's a storm. A whirlwind of terror and rage building up with the two instigators in the middle, infrequently bashing against each other in a spinning cataclysm that sends shockwaves throughout an entranced world. Yesterday a volcano erupted dead in the centre, with a botched handshake, a tunnel spat and an over-zealous celebration just a handful of the outrageous incidents.

It's a real mess of blame and shifted responsibility. It needs somebody reasonable to stretch out the situation like a wet towel, and point out exactly where each of the stains are and who's fault they were. What? Oh, did you just mutter "You should do it then". Well, that's extremely kind of you. I didn't expect that. Well alright then, I'll give it a shot if you really think I can.

Actually, I don't need to. Alan Green did a perfect job of diffusing the situation of 606 earlier, by consistently pressing forward the notion that Suarez had no obligation to shake Evra's hand whilst feigning condemnation of the very same act. He also started claiming that Suarez couldn't be a racist, because he shook the hands of a few other black people, which is akin to saying that Nick Griffin isn't racist because he ate curry once. People rightly came in to criticise Green, and as he began to backtrack on his comments, everyone became so confused about what his point was that I think they actually broke him. At the end he started saying "Oh, it's been a long day at work". It was utterly bizarre radio.

But either way, I don't think the incident is that hard to judge when you look at it. Let's put aside, for one moment, the original incident of racial abuse and whether or not Suarez's alleged comments did actually happen. Ignore that point for one second. Suarez really should have looked at how this whole incident has affected his reputation and the way he is perceived. Regardless of the incessant details of the incident a few months ago, Suarez must have been aware that a failure to shake Evra's hand was going to look tremendously petulant. It was really idiotic. Of course, Suarez has the right not to shake Evra's hand, but if he doesn't then not only is he an idiot, but he opens himself to any racially-charged perceptions people may see in his refusal. Just because you have the right to do something doesn't mean you want be correctly condemned if you do it.

Now this whole incident has led to people questioning the validity of the handshake at the beginning of the football match. I still think it's an important facet of a football game. It's good to have a showing of respect towards your opponent before the game, and it encourages gentlemanly conduct. People may renege on the handshake in severe cases but this is not something that incites a feud, it merely confirms it. Some have suggested that a handshake should take place at the end of the game, but I can't see that becoming a formal part of routine, and I believe this would be even more of a problem on occasions where things got heated on the pitch.

So Suarez not shaking Evra's hand was stupid. Really stupid. And all those people posting images and videos trying to prove Evra was actually the one who rejected the handshake are truly laughable. It's like a mini-faction of conspiracy theorists have infiltrated football, showing highly deceptive images and pointing out minute details whilst ignoring the bigger picture. I'm surprised they're not calling it an inside job, to be honest. Let's be fair though, Evra does seem to be a little hesitant about the handshake, but can you blame him? Suarez supposedly racially abused Evra, it's not as if Patrice is going to give him the firmest of handshakes. Either way, he was not the one who didn't offer his hand.

After a slow half of football came a little bit more anger from Suarez. Clearly riled up about something (I'm not exactly sure what considering it was him who decided not to participate in the handshake - seriously, what was he expecting?) he reacted very badly to a perfectly fair Rio Ferdinand tackle, and violently kicked the ball away in fury as the half-time whistle was blown. Little is known of what followed, but police and stewards were forced to break up a brewing rage in the tunnel. I'm going to go on a whim and say that Suarez and Evra were maybe involved in that, but the post-match comments don't seem to allude to what really happened there, so it's difficult to say. For all we know, it could have been Carroll and Berbatov having a lazy fight where they just exasperatedly pushed each other a bit before going off for a nap...

Thankfully, a football match pushed it's way out of the mud and took a deep breath of the cold wintry air, allowing itself to manifest as a 2-1 victory to Manchester United. It was a worthy result that meant a lot to the United team, but Evra's post-match antics were undoubtedly uncalled for. Though I wouldn't say the incident was of the severity of Suarez's (and almost certainly was instigated by the Uruguayan anyway), clearly Evra's only achievement was to antagonise the situation even further, which was rather reckless of him.

So that was the on-field action and it's tempting to say that had the managers both condemned their players' acts of foolishness and said little more on the incident, a significant amount less would have been made out of the nasty debacle. I use the word 'tempting' because that's almost certainly not true, but it's a nice thought anyway. Instead, Kenny Dalglish and Alex Ferguson both made controversial statements, although it's no doubt who's interview came across worse. King Kenny's interview seemed to be going smoothly enough, but when questioned about the handshake incident, Dalglish denied that he was aware that it happened (which I struggle to believe) and consequently got furious at Geoff Shreeves for blaming Suarez for anything, mumbling something about the fans and then ending the interview.

Alex Ferguson's comments were a little inflammatory as well. He suggested that Liverpool should sell Suarez in what was otherwise a fairly reasonable interview. It was a rash comment maybe, but nothing more than that. I know it seems like I'm condemning Liverpool a lot harder at the moment, but the truth is when you compare these things objectively, there's really little argument to be had. Whilst Ferguson was calm and addressed all the incidents, Dalglish became incandescent as soon as Suarez was in any way condemned. There's little way to justify it in any other light.

However, today's apologies have been more than welcomed. Suarez has issued a statement admitting he 'got things wrong', and Dalglish accepted that he had not 'conducted himself in a way befitting of a Liverpool manager. These apologies, whether they are sincere or not, should be embraced by all fans, especially Liverpool supporters. Yesterday's incidents were an unfortunate mix of anger and bitterness that just happened to rear their ugly heads. They were mistakes, and it's good to see that both Suarez and Dalglish are willing to put their hands up to them. United also released a statement that looked to put a chunky bucket of water over the fire, meaning both clubs are happy to move away from the trouble.

So should Ferguson and Evra apologise? I don't think Ferguson should. Perhaps it would be good form If Evra admitted his celebrations were over-zealous, but I'm not sure it's necessary now. Either way, we have to move on from this tremendous farce. Not only does it not paint a good image of English football, but when other black players see the ridiculous furore that has happened thanks to racial abuse being reported, it will only serve to discourage them from alerting people to when they are racially abused themselves. If this sort of thing is allowed to drag so far in the future, complaining about racial abuse will just be seen as a hassle, followed by a long, unhappy grudge.

Furthermore, the faction of Liverpool supporters that are still showing ardent defence for Suarez need to start considering that their heroes may not just be honorable victims. Whilst the merits of an independent report can be disputed (if you're into that sort of thing), what happened yesterday was plain to see. I'm amazed that some people seem capable of upholding this victimisation view though - really, it's akin to spinning a helicopter in a beach hut, but the best step would be to understand that this was an unpleasant incident that doesn't need to be stretched on any further, and move on.

I haven't helped by talking about it again though.

Saturday, 7 January 2012

Racism, Football and Twitter

Last night’s incident at Anfield involving Tom Adeyemi leaves another bad taste in a mouth already filled with unpleasant sensation. The alleged racist abuse the young Oldham defender suffered from the ugly mouth of a fan has capped a string of incidents in the last few weeks that have the unshakable theme of racial abuse. It would seem that, despite Sepp Blatter’s ill-judged assertion, racism continues to rear its putrid head in English football.

It’s important to stress that there’s no confirmation the incident at Anfield last night was racially motivated, but it would seem very likely given both the accounts of those in the area around the incident and the distraught reaction of Adeyemi himself. This follows the long-winded dispute between Luis Suarez and Patrice Evra following the reported racist slur the Uruguayan used.

Both incidents involve Liverpool, but it’s not fair at all to tar the whole club and fanbase with the same brush. I think any club has a handful of despicable, racist idiots in the stands and it wouldn’t be right to pretend that Liverpool are the only club in the world in which that is the case. While racist chanting and the like is a thing of the past, you just have to look around you in this country to see plenty of racist idiots around.

Certainly, Liverpool Football Club reacted badly to the Suarez case with the overblown support, prior to a muted retraction when the FA’s report came out and showed the nature of Suarez’s statements, along with the lack of veracity the Uruguayan showed throughout the saga. Despite the lack of appreciation for the serious nature of the incident, we can forgive Liverpool Football Club some misplaced trust in one of their employees should they deal swiftly and with conviction with regards to this racist idiot of a ‘fan’.

Why is it that these incidents seem to have suddenly flared up in such succession though? I think there’s a lot of reasons (mostly boring political ones that make no sense). In truth, it all kicked off with the John Terry incident. His supposed racially motivated shout seemed like a moment of ignorance, frustration and nastiness. It seems as if Terry never thought he’d be caught, but the video clip of him shouting the alleged phrase was key in outing this particular incident. It perhaps suggests that more of this sort of thing occurs on the football pitch, but goes unreported.

For Suarez, it was a similar case. He claimed to be ignorant of the fact that the term ‘negro’ could be seen as offensive, but upon looking at the way in which the term was used in the report of the incident, it seems impossible that Suarez was unaware he was being grossly offensive. Of course, the FA had no concrete proof that all these things were shouted, but the nature of the case would suggest that there were at least a few assertions to that effect.

Some people seem to think that the victims of these attacks are looking for trouble. I don’t think that can be true at all. For Evra, he was branded a liar and had to go through a drawn out case with the FA over the incident. Unless he had a severe personal problem with Luis Suarez, I can’t think why Evra would want to cause such fuss if no racial abuse had taken place. Same with Adeyemi, people were saying that he was having a bad game and decided to selectively hear a racist shout. I’m not sure what that’s supposed to mean; why would Adeyemi want a reason to cry on the football pitch. That just sounds stupid to me.

You see, this sort of condemnation of anyone who’s prepared to step forward and call out racist abuse only serves to stop players from coming forward in the future. If Evra had kept quiet about Suarez, or if Adeyemi had not confronted the abuse he received, or if John Terry hadn’t been caught on video, players and fans around them may have considered that sort of behaviour to be acceptable because it wasn’t followed up by anyone. It’s easy for things like that to become the norm, so it’s a good thing that there are players willing to express the fact that this is unacceptable.

These incidents have led to a lot of frustrated fans. They are either totally offended that one of their players or fellow supporters is being condemned, want to cover up their ears and pretend that racism in football isn’t a problem, or are just flagrant racists. The latter of those three is thankfully the least common, but unfortunately more nastiness occurred when Stan Collymore was subject to racial abuse on Twitter. Sadly, the internet is an effective framework for allowing this sort of thing to be more outspoken and more likely. 

However, internet warriors are a different sort of people from actual football fans. The internet does have a lot of kitsch, tongue-in-cheek racism that some people may find offensive, but is done with a beam of irony. Unfortunately though, there are a lot of impressionable people that will take all this literally, and they don’t care that their hurtful comments are being directed at real people. Now I don’t really like Stan Collymore when he’s on the radio or anything, but I know he is a real person and I would feel embarrassed to send him something insulting over Twitter. It seems some people are happy to hide behind their keyboards and throw abuse wherever they feel is necessary.

He’s been arrested now though (the racist, no Collymore).

Thursday, 17 November 2011

A Sepp too far.

Sepp Blatter has always been a bit of a knob. That’s by no means the most eloquent opening sentence I’ve ever used, but I don’t think there’s any need to be more whimsical and articulate about it. Sepp Blatter is a knob, and an impressively persistent one at that. Blatter has made a game out of being a walking, talking disaster, and his career has revolved around outdoing his previous stupidity.
Now he’s gone and said something a fair bit more idiotic than usual. Yes, even crazier than his comments about how women’s football should introduce hot pants to make it more popular. Even more ill-judged than his comparison of footballers to slaves. Even more bizarre than his idea of scrapping the offside rule. Even more insensitive than his comments that homosexual supporters should “refrain from sexual activity” in Qatar. If they gave awards for foolish statements, Sepp Blatter would have a trophy cabinet the size of London. This week, Blatter accomplished his pièce de résistance.
“There is no racism” Blatter remarked, adding “The one affected by this should say this is a game and shake hands”.
“Congratulations Blatter” cried football. “What awesome timing and understanding”.
It’s not difficult to see where the controversy is coming from. To even suggest that a victim of racial abuse should shake his perpetrators hand is an inexplicable point to make. There’s a reason Wayne Bridge doesn’t shake John Terry’s hand anymore – Because when someone else has done something wrong, it’s their obligation to appease the situation, not the victim’s. Blatter’s comments, though I’m sure he didn’t quite mean it as strongly as this, suggest a ‘get over it attitude’.
It’s difficult to know what Blatter was really thinking when he made these comments, but I’ll give it a shot. I believe that Blatter was getting fed up with the alleged racism on the pitch, didn’t see it as a problem and wanted to deny it outright in order to squash the situation entirely. However, it’s backfired spectacularly because if anything, the head of football’s governing body showing a lack of compassion for victims of racial abuse on the pitch is only going to add a ton of coal to the fire.
It’s usually important not to overreact to these statements, especially considering the obstacle of the antagonist having to break through the language barrier. Often I think it’s worth giving the benefit of the doubt in these situations, because things can so easily be misconstrued and the media can make more of certain comments that were perhaps unintended.
For example, a few weeks ago Man United ‘keeper Tomasz Kuszczak was vilified for using the term ‘slave’ in describing his situation at the club. Whilst the comparison is senseless, nobody can claim that they have never hyperbolised a bit. I think Kuszczak’s faux pas was just a small misunderstanding, but all it took was one of these instances and the press could paint it as an indictment of the ‘out-of-touch’ footballers.
However, I don’t think we can give Blatter any leeway here. He not only made some very clear statements (“There is no racism… shake hands”), but he is the head of FIFA. That shouldn’t be a position you attain if you can’t say what you mean, and you make comments contrary to your intentions. Sepp Blatter is not someone who is constantly misunderstood. Like I said, he’s a knob.
FIFA image has collapsed more dramatically than the Berlin Wall. They have totally lost the confidence of the fans thanks to repeated poor decisions and allegations of corruption. They desperately need a change, and I think it’s about time that the master of the gaffe himself stepped down. Like a true artist, Blatter has finished with his final flourish – a beautifully crass comment about racial abuse. Now he must step down.